Welding is a precise art, and every detail counts. One seemingly small aspect, like a tack weld, can make a big difference in the final outcome. But what happens if one of those tack welds breaks?

Yes, it matters if a tack weld breaks because it holds the pieces of an item in place during welding. If one fails, the parts can shift out of alignment, leading to potential defects in the final weld. This misalignment can compromise the integrity of the entire project.

In this blog post, we’ll discuss what happens when a tack weld breaks during welding and share some tips to help prevent them from breaking in the first place. 

What is Tack Welding?

Tack welding is a temporary welding process that holds metal pieces together at the start of a welding project. Its main purpose is to securely position workpieces in the right alignment and placement before the final weld. You perform tack welding using the same method that will be used for the final weld, such as MIG or TIG welding.

Clamps and magnets can sometimes hold joints together before tacking. But tack welds grip better when parts experience internal or external forces during welding. This helps ensure a quality weld.

Some features of tack welding are: 

• Small Welds: Instead of long welds, tack welds are tiny spots, usually about 1/4 to 1/2 inch long.
• Support under Stress: Tack welds can absorb stresses that arise during welding, making them more reliable than clamps or magnets alone.
• Common in Various Industries: Precision machining companies apply this technique in different manufacturing fields, such as sheet metal fabrication and precision machining parts. Construction industries also use it, especially for large structures like bridges.

Does It Matter If One Of The Tack Welds Breaks During Welding?

If a tack weld breaks, it can lead to misalignment, distortion, incorrect gap, and even poor final products. Let’s discuss the issues in detail:

a. Misalignment

When components aren’t lined up correctly, it affects the quality of the final weld. Tack welds hold parts in place before the main welding happens. If a tack weld breaks, those parts can shift, causing misalignment. It can lead to a weld that doesn’t match the design, weakening the overall assembly.

Another problem of misalignment is gap variation. It impacts how well the final weld bonds because the gap between components changes. If the gap is too wide, the weld might not fuse properly, causing weak spots. 

Fit-up issues also arise from misalignment. If pieces don’t fit together properly, creating a clean weld becomes challenging. This can result in a messy appearance and a weak joint.

b. Distortion

A broken tack weld can cause the movement of the pieces, leading to dimensional inaccuracies.

Welding introduces heat into the metal, causing it to expand and contract. Tack welds help to counteract this thermal expansion and prevent excessive distortion. When a tack weld breaks, the components have more space to move, leading to increased distortion.

Such movements may result in dimensional inaccuracies. It’s a critical issue in applications where precise dimensions are required, such as in aerospace or automotive industries.

Another issue with distortion is that it creates stress points in the weld. These stress concentrations can weaken the joint, making it more likely to crack over time. 

Product assembly becomes tricky because of distorting parts. It can take extra time to fit everything together, which raises labor costs and increases the risk of damaging the components. 

c. Incomplete Fusion

When tack welds break, they create gaps that can be too wide for the molten weld metal to fill. If the space is too large, the tack welder may struggle to bridge it completely. As a result, there could be unmelted areas in the weld, which are weak spots. These weak spots can make the entire joint vulnerable, increasing the risk of failure.

Additionally, if a tack weld breaks, it can affect the welder’s technique. The welder might find it hard to control the welding torch or filler metal effectively. This difficulty can prevent the molten metal from penetrating properly into the gaps. As a result, the connection between the weld metal and the base metal suffers, leading to incomplete fusion.

d. Reinforcement Problems

Weld reinforcement is the extra layer of weld metal that sits above the base materials. Too much or too little of it can cause issues. 

Since broken tack welds can cause gap variation, a welder may add more metal to fix this. However, this can create an uneven bead, where some parts have too much reinforcement and others have too little. Not only does this affect strength, but it also impacts how the finished weld looks.

The problems don’t just stop at appearance. An uneven or excessively reinforced weld can weaken the joint. Areas with too much reinforcement may develop cracks over time due to stress. Meanwhile, spots with too little reinforcement might not be strong enough for their intended use. 

e. Potential for Defects

For a broken one, the remaining tack welds have to carry more weight and stress. This added pressure can lead to problems in the final weld.

One major risk is crack formation. Increased load can crack the nearby bead or the remaining ones. These cracks may spread into the final weld, weakening it. If this happens, the weld might not hold up under pressure, which is a big concern for safety and durability.

Another issue is porosity. Broken tack welds can disrupt the flow of the welding arc and the protective gas used during welding. This disruption can lead to gas pockets trapped in the weld, known as porosity. These tiny holes can make the weld weaker and less reliable.

f. Time and Resource Waste

When a tack weld is broken, you have to repair or replace it, requiring additional time and filler material. The wastage will be even bigger if you need to rework each of the tack welds. 

In the worst cases, a broken weld can ruin an entire workpiece. If the damage is too severe, scrapping the piece might be necessary. This not only wastes materials but also costs a lot of money. The financial impact can be significant, especially if production schedules are pushed back.

How to Avoid Tack Welds Breaks During Welding

Preventing the breaking of tack welds is crucial for a successful welding process. Here are some key steps you can take:

Prepare the Workpiece

Before welding, take a moment to prepare your materials. Clean the surfaces thoroughly. Dirt, grease, and rust can weaken your tack welds, making them more likely to fail.

Check the fit-up of your pieces. They should fit snugly together. Gaps or misalignments can create extra stress on those little welds.

Using clamps is a smart move, too. They help hold everything in place and reduce stress on the tack welds.

Apply Proper Techniques

The skill of the welder matters a lot because broken tack welds could be the result of incorrect techniques. 

Make sure your tack welds are big enough for the thickness of your materials. If you use a tack that’s too small, it might snap easily. Also, think about penetration. Your tack weld should sink into the base metal. If it’s too shallow, it can break under pressure.

Cooling is also important. After you make a tack weld, let it cool completely before you start welding the main joints. If you rush this step, thermal stress can cause breaks. Finally, be smart about where you place your tacks. Distribute them evenly to avoid putting too much stress in one spot.

Inspect Carefully

Always start with a visual inspection. Look closely at your tack welds for any cracks or defects. If you see anything unusual, fix it before moving on. It’s better to catch problems early than to deal with them later.

You might also want to do a test weld on a scrap piece of metal. This allows you to check the strength of your tack welds. Testing helps you see how well they hold up under pressure.

By following these guidelines, you can reduce the risk of tack weld breaking and improve the overall quality of your welds.

Conclusion

A broken tack weld can ruin your entire welding project. So, you should take the time to prepare materials carefully, use proper welding techniques, and inspect tack welds thoroughly to prevent breaks and get more reliable final welds.

Do you need custom sheet metal prototyping or high-quality precision parts? Get precision machining services from Zintilon. Our skilled workers can meet your production needs in the quickest time possible. Contact for a free quote.