The best party games have one rule and start an argument. This one qualifies. You pick a topic, the group sorts a list of things into rows from best to worst, and everyone discovers that the person they have known for ten years thinks pineapple belongs on pizza.
It needs no cards, no board and no scorekeeping. Here is how to run it well, plus some real results that show which topics are worth choosing.
The basic game
A tier list is a ranking in rows. The top row is traditionally labelled “S”, then A, B, C and D below it. Several things can sit in the same row, which is what makes it a group game: you do not need to agree on an exact order, only on roughly how good something is.
- Pick a topic and 10 to 15 items. Everyone must have an opinion on every item. Pizza toppings work. Nineteenth-century novels do not.
- Put the items where everyone can see them. Sticky notes on a door work. On a TV with a laptop plugged in, a text tier list maker lets you paste the list, one item per line, and drag the names into rows.
- Take turns. Each person places one item in a row and gives one sentence of reasoning.
- Allow one veto each. Any player may, once per game, move someone else’s item one row up or down. Vetoes are where the evening happens.
- Stop when the list is placed. Take a photo. Somebody will want it as evidence later.
A round takes fifteen to twenty minutes with six people.
What actually happens: three small polls
I run a free tier list site with open community boards, where anyone can drag items into tiers and add their vote to a running total. The numbers are small and the voters chose to take part, so treat them as a snapshot of a few groups and nothing grander. They are useful for one thing: showing where people agree and where they split.
Pizza toppings (6 voters). Extra cheese went in the top tier for every single person who placed it. Pepperoni was just behind. Anchovies came last, with spinach and jalapeño close by, and pineapple sat fourth from the bottom. A topic like this has a boring top and a lively lower half.
Candy (10 voters). KitKat and Twix came out on top; six of the ten put Twix in the top tier. Twizzlers finished last and did not receive one top-tier vote from anybody.
Fast food (12 voters). Chick-fil-A, Taco Bell and Domino’s led. Burger King was last, and McDonald’s landed in the bottom four. The biggest chain in the room was nobody’s favourite, which is a reliable way to start a conversation.
The pattern to notice is that the fun is never at the top. Everyone agrees cheese is good. The game lives in the middle and the bottom, where one person’s comfort food is another person’s last resort.
Choosing a topic that works
A good topic passes three tests.
Everyone has tried everything on the list. If two guests have never eaten at half the chains, they are spectators.
Nothing on it is personal. Rank snacks, films and holidays. Do not rank mutual friends, exes or each other’s cooking. This sounds obvious until the third drink.
The middle is contested. If you can predict the whole board, pick something else.
Topics that reliably work: pizza toppings, breakfast cereals, chocolate bars, fast food chains, film sequels, board games, public holidays, biscuits, karaoke songs, ways to cook a potato.
Topics that fall flat: anything where one item is plainly the best (the board is done in a minute) and anything requiring knowledge (it turns into a quiz, and quizzes have losers).
Three ways to play
Consensus. The rules above. Best for six or fewer, and for groups who enjoy talking.
Blind ranking. Items are revealed one at a time and must be placed before the next one appears. No moving anything afterwards. The agony of putting something in the top tier and then seeing a better item come up is the entire game. Good for larger groups, because it is fast.
Guess the host. One person ranks the list in secret. Everyone else builds the board they think that person made. Score a point for each item in the right row. This one is excellent for couples and old friends, and occasionally a little too revealing.
All three work over a video call as well: one person shares the board and places the tiles for everyone.
Hosting notes
Limit the list. Fifteen items is the ceiling. Past that, the last few get dumped in the middle by people who want another drink.
Name a tie-breaker. When the room is deadlocked, the host decides, or the item goes to a coin toss. Do not let one topping take ten minutes.
Rename the rows if your guests do not play games. “Would fight for it / Happy to see it / Fine / Only if hungry / No” needs no explanation.
Feed people the topic. Rank the crisps while eating the crisps. A tasting flight of five supermarket colas, ranked blind, is a whole evening for the price of five bottles.
Keep the board. Print it or post it in the group chat. A bad ranking, properly preserved, can be brought up at gatherings for years.
That last point is the real reason the game works. Nobody remembers who won at charades. Everybody remembers who put anchovies at the top.
Farasat Abbas Naqvi is an engineer who builds practical web tools. He created MyTierMaker, a free tier list site with open community polls.
