Designing a new car, building on skyscraper or production of medical appliances. Regardless of the scenario, they require materials that can withstand stress & strain without wearing out. But how do you know they meet the grade? Here comes the importance of hardness testing — a key process to determine substance durability both surface and product standpoints.
Two of these methods consistently shine through: the Brinell Hardness Tester and Rockwell Hardness Testers. This blog will detail both these testing methods along with differences in their features, benefits and use cases so that you can make an informed decision.
What is Hardness Testing?
This type of hardness testing is one of the most primary experiments in material science to determine mechanical deformation undergo by a specimen. It is an important factor in quality control, material selection and product life. Oftentimes, mechanical engineers need information on material properties such as wear resistance, strength and ductility; this testing can be carried out via a variety of hardness tests. Although there are many types of hardness test methods, Brinell and Rockwell tests have been chosen as the two most popular to be used globally because they are both accurate and reliable.
The Brinell Hardness Tester
The Brinell hardness tester,[1] invented by Johan August Brinell in 1900, was the first widely used standardized hardness test. Introduced a simple, effective way to determine the hardness of metals and alloys that completely changed how material testing was done.
Working of Brinell Hardness Tester
The Brinell test is usually conducted by pressing a hard steel or carbide sphere indenter into the material surface with a defined size and force. The diameter of the indentation produced by such an indenter is measured, and Brinell hardness number (BHN) can be calculated according to formula:
BHN = (2P) / (πD(D – √(D² – d²)))
where:
PPP is the applied force.
Having in above formula DDD is the diameter of the ball indenter.
ddd is the diameter of the scoring.
This method is especially great for testing of materials that have large or inhomogeneous grain structures – such as castings and forgings.
Feature of Brinell Hardness Tester
- Suitability: Test almost all type of material metal and non-metal
- Deep Indentation: Contributes to a global hardness over an extended region, attenuating localized softness.
- Simpler: Since the test process is simple and can be easily carried out
- Drawbacks of the Brinell Method
- Application: Must be applied to an even, clean surface for true readings.
Large indentation may not suitable for thin or small samples Indentation Size
This is a process that takes time, because we must take an indentation diameter and then perform the double calculation of BHN.
The Rockwell Hardness Tester
The Rockwell hardness tester, on the other hand, was developed by Stanley Rockwell in 1919 to find a way around some of the problems with Brinell. Nowadays, it ranks as one of the most populars methods for hardness testing in numerous countries across the globe.
How Does the Rockwell Hardness Tester Do?
The latter indicates how deep an indenter penetrates under a large load relative to the deformation made by a preliminary load, Results of Rockwell test Here are the steps taken as part of this process:
The material undergoes a minor load called the initial (minor) load.
This was followed by the application of a major load inducing further penetration.
The primary load is unladen, and the penetration depth difference from the preliminary load can be measured.
The Rockwell hardness number (HR) is read directly from the testing machine and ranges across scales A, B, C… etc., based on applications for a wide range of materials.
Benefits of The Rockwell Hardness Tester
Quick – Gives a hardness reading instantly without making an optical routine’),(‘flip-box-invalid feverillary’).
- Ease of Use: User Friendly, Efficient Due to the direct readout
- Scalability: This provides cooperates with the option of choosing for materials made from various scales and are fit to work within different hardness ranges.
The Rockwell Method is More Limited
- Surface Sensitivity: Higher sensitivity to surface conditions and a more elaborate sample preparation are vital in order
- These are limited to the smaller indentations, and they may not be suitable for materials that have coarser or more irregular grain structures.
- Cost of equipment: Typically higher since testing machines is more complicated.
Brinell vs Rockwell Hardness Testers Comparisons
Precision and Accuracy
Both the hardness tester are used for accurate and precise hardness measurement however depending upon material to use and its application required, one needs to choose them accordingly. Brinell tests work well for materials with large structures, whereas Rockwell gives instant and easy to read results on a multitude of different material types.
Types of Materials
Brinell is recommended for castings, forgins and uneven grain structured materials Rockwell has the ability to be used in many different applications, from metals or polymers to even harder materials.
Simple and Fast
Rockwell tests provide simple and direct readouts, saving time over the need for post-test calculations. Even though Brinell tests are easy to perform, they take much longer for measurement and calculation.
Expense and maintenance of equipment
Rockwell testers are more affordable, as they are less complex and require just one application of manual force. Brinell testers usually cost less, while being more difficult to use.
Situations for Each Method
Opt for Brinell when testing large, rough materials where an average over a wide area is desired. If your samples are smoother then Rockwell for quick and accurate measurements.
Applications
Automotive Industry
Brinell and Rockwell testing are common tests in the automotive industry. Brinell tests are for bigger parts, such as cast engine blocks and Rockwell testing gets done on smaller precision components like gears / bearings.
Aerospace Sector
These Rockwell hardness testers come in handy for the aerospace industry due to their quick functionality that analyzes materials commonly used for aircraft components. Brinell testers are reserved for structural elements which will endure where “bulk hardness” is a more important characteristic.
Manufacturing, and Quality Control
Rockwell testers find their usefulness in general manufacturing where they are quick and easy to use along your production lines for providing fast quality control. Foundries and forging operations that need to know the general hardness of a material use Brinell testers.
How To Select The Best Hardness Tester For Your Needs
Factors to consider when Choosing between Brinell and Rockwell hardness testers Include;
Material Type: This means which kind of materials you will be testing. Brinell is much better suited to coarse structures and if you perform Rockwell on rough, uneven surfaces the results would not be a fair indication of material properties.
Testing Speed: How fast do you need the results? Rockwell supports quick readouts.
Size and Shape of Sample specimen: Large rough samples are more suitable for Brinell because Small, delicate or difficult to work on the surfaces is ideal sample condition for Rockwell.
Price: Rockwell testers are pricier but allow better throughput. Brinell testers are the most affordable, but they need manual operation.
Your hardness tester can either make or break you in the materials testing industry. Although both the Brinell and Rockwell methods have their own respective merits, they serve different purposes. Knowing these differences will allow you to choose the most suitable method for your exact requirements, so that results may be both accurate and reliable.
To know more about hardness testing and to see advanced technology of testing visit WorldofTest.com.